Facilitating Peer Review Activities and Assignments
Overview
Peer review assignments can be a powerful way for students to engage with each other and expand their own perspectives of what it means to be a reader, writer, and thinker in their courses. As Paul Bloomberg, et. al. (2019) note, “requiring students to elaborate and justify their [own] thinking forces them [students] to think more clearly.” By reviewing and commenting on peer-created content, students can consolidate their own understanding of a particular topic, all while cultivating a greater sense of peer community and learning.
If students are concerned with their grades and the grading process, involving students in peer review also gives them an opportunity to be in the role of “assessor,” giving them some deeper insights into what it looks like to apply their instructor’s assessment criteria themselves. In other words, peer review engages students in the assessment process in a way that may deepen their insight (and lessen their anxiety) about giving and receiving feedback.
The most successful peer review assignments encourage students to provide feedback that’s respectful, constructive, and substantive. However, students will need some coaching and structure to actualize these outcomes. To design successful peer review assignments, consider the following research-based strategies for structuring and facilitating peer review with your students.
Before Assigning Peer Review
Students will have different prior experiences with peer review and other kinds of group work assignments. Before introducing a peer review assignment in your own course, consider giving students an opportunity to share what their prior experiences have been like in the form of an out-of-class survey. This can give you an opportunity to address students’ prior concerns and to elevate prior highlights that students themselves have experienced. Addressing students’ concerns and assumptions up front can help students approach the peer review assignment in your course from a fresh perspective. This can also be a useful moment to explain why you are using peer review in the first place. Students are often more willing to engage when they understand that peer review is not just busywork, but a structured opportunity to practice judgement and revision.
Designing a Peer Review Assignment
Creating structure is key to a successful peer review assignment. This can take the form of providing examples, templates, or worksheets to students so that they can have clearer expectations of how to engage with each other in the peer review process. The clearer the expectations students have for the assignment, the more likely they are to engage in a successful peer review process.
One useful way to think about peer review design is to plan for three stages: I. preparing students to give feedback, II. facilitating the review process itself, and III. helping students using the feedback they receive.
Prepare Students to Give Feedback
Provide students with a peer review worksheet or rubric for them to use as foundational criteria for assessing their peers’ writing. Alternatively, facilitate an activity where the students co-create a rubric, asking the students themselves to identify which criteria they think are most important to assess when commenting on each others’ writing.
Give students a sample paper to review and comment on in class using the agreed-upon peer review guidelines (i.e. the co-developed rubric or the instructor-developed worksheet/rubric). Ask students to share the peer review feedback they’ve provided for the in-class sample. Use the class time to uplift example comments that are clear, specific, and constructive so that students have a clear sense of the types of feedback that can most help their peers improve.
Without examples, students may default to comments that are overly general (“This was good”) or overly directive (“You should rewrite this whole section”) rather than feedback that helps a peer see what is working, what is unclear, and what could be strengthened.
Facilitate the Peer Review Process
Facilitate the peer review assignment itself; this could take the form of either an out-of-class or in-class activity. Regardless of whether the peer review activity is facilitated, consider providing students with some additional advice, including:
- Instruct students to provide feedback as if they were speaking to the writer or presenter directly. This will remind students that their peers may be sensitive to feedback they are receiving; it is worth preventing students from leaving overly harsh feedback.
- Provide time limits for peer review sessions. If facilitating peer review in-class, let students know how long they have to engage in peer review. If facilitating peer review outside of class, set defined deadlines and recommended timeframes for leaving feedback for peers.
- Remind students that they are leaving feedback based on their own vantage point and experience of the writing. Their feedback should not be an attempt to anticipate how their instructor will leave feedback or respond to the student’s work.
Help Students in Using Feedback
Upon completion of the peer review process, encourage students to summarize the feedback they’ve received and create a potential revision plan that incorporates some of the peer review feedback. Students should recognize that they don’t have to accept all of the feedback they’ve received, but they should take time to process the feedback they have received and look for common themes that have emerged from the feedback.
Often when students complete the feedback exchange, they’re unsure what to do next. Encouraging them to identify patterns across comments, decide which suggestions are most useful, and make a plan revisions, help students understand how to use feedback to strengthen their work.
Make space for some reflection. Consider protecting some time in-class to discuss how the process worked or distribute a survey to students after the assignment has been completed to collect their feedback on how the process went and what they would suggest be designed differently for a subsequent iteration of the peer review process.
Teaching Peer Review Resources
If you are looking for additional resources or ready-made templates that support the implementation of peer review in your class context, consider using resources from the Center for Teaching and Learning’s bCourses site, “How to Successfully Participate in Peer Review/Feedback.” This resource site includes:
- Suggestions written for students to help them write their feedback effectively
- Sample sentence stems/prompts for student peer response
- Reflection prompts that support students in processing the feedback they received from the peer review process
References
Bloomberg, P., Pitchford, B., and Vandal, K.(2019). Peer Power: Unite, Learn and Prosper, Activate and Assessment Revolution. San Diego:Mimi and Todd Press
Cornell: Teaching students to evaluate each other Center for Teaching Innovation